Gadenin日本語Get the app

When Are Apples Ripe? The Lift Test and How to Store the Crop

A ripe apple comes away when you lift and tilt it, stalk and all. If you are pulling, it is not ready, and you are tearing off next year's spur.

Lift the apple, do not pull it

The single most reliable ripeness test on an apple tree costs nothing and takes two seconds. Cup the apple in your palm, lift it upwards and give it a slight twist. A ripe apple parts from the spur cleanly at the stalk, with the stalk still attached to the fruit. An unripe apple resists, and if you pull harder you either tear the stalk out of the apple or snap the whole spur off the branch.

That last point is why technique matters beyond this year's crop. The spur you rip off was going to carry fruit for the next decade. An apple missing its stalk also rots quickly in store, because the torn end is an open wound.

Test the apples on the outside of the tree and on the sunny side first; they ripen days or weeks before the shaded interior fruit. Color alone is a poor guide, because the sunny cheek reddens long before the flesh is ready, and some apples are barely colored when perfectly ripe.

  1. Cup and lift Hold the fruit in your whole hand, not by the fingertips, which bruises it. Lift it so the stalk is pushed upwards towards the branch and twist gently.
  2. Stop if it resists If it does not release with light pressure, leave it and try again in three or four days. Nothing is gained by forcing it, and an apple picked a week early never develops full flavor off the tree.
  3. Check the ground A few sound, undamaged apples dropping naturally from the tree is the classic signal that picking has started. Windfalls after a gale mean nothing; look for clean fruit falling in still weather.
  4. Cut one open Halve a sample apple. Ripe pips are dark brown throughout. White or pale tan pips mean it needs longer, though on very early varieties the pips darken before the flesh is at its best.

Handle picked apples as if they were eggs. A bruise you cannot see today is a brown patch in three weeks, and one rotting apple will take the rest of the box with it.

The other ripeness signals, and what each is worth

No single indicator is enough on its own; use two or three together. Ground color is the most useful of the visual checks: ignore the red flush and look at the background color between it, which shifts from a hard grass green to a lighter yellow-green or cream as the fruit ripens.

Days from full bloom is a surprisingly steady figure for a given variety in a given garden, which is exactly why recording it pays. Early apples run roughly 90 to 110 days from bloom, mid-season around 120 to 145, and late keepers 150 days or more. Once you have that number for your own tree, you know within a week when to start testing.

IndicatorNot readyReadyHow much to trust it
Lift-and-twistResists, stalk tearsParts cleanly with stalkHigh; the primary test
Pip colorWhite or pale tanDark brown throughoutHigh on mid and late apples
Ground colorHard grass greenYellow-green or creamGood; ignore the red flush
Natural dropNone, or only wind damageSound fruit falling in still airGood on early apples
TasteStarchy, hard, flatSweet, aromatic, crispGood, but costs you an apple each time
Days from bloomWell under the usual countWithin a week of itHigh once you have recorded two seasons

Pick over the tree several times

A tree does not ripen all at once. Depending on the variety, picking runs over two to four weeks, and stripping the whole tree in one afternoon guarantees that a third of it is underripe and a third is over. Go through the tree every four or five days, taking only what lifts cleanly.

Start with the fruit on the outside and the sunny side, and finish with the shaded fruit low and inside the canopy. The exception is a tree you intend to store: interior fruit is often slightly smaller, denser and keeps better than the big sunny-side apples, so it is worth keeping them separated as you pick.

Late-keeping varieties are picked before they are pleasant to eat. They come off the tree hard and sharp and develop their flavor over weeks in store. If you wait until a late apple tastes good on the tree, it is already past its keeping condition and will go mealy in the box.

Thin earlier if you want fruit worth picking

Harvest quality is largely decided months earlier, at thinning. A tree left to carry everything it sets produces a mass of small, poorly colored apples, splits its own limbs, and then takes the following year off. Thinning is not optional maintenance; it is the difference between fruit and clutter.

Once the natural early-summer drop has finished, reduce each cluster to one fruit, keeping the largest and best-shaped, which is usually the central king fruit unless it is misshapen. Aim for one apple every four to six inches (10-15 cm) along the branch. On a dwarf tree, a rough guide is around thirty leaves to support one apple.

The other reason to thin is biennial bearing. Next year's fruit buds form during this summer, while the tree is carrying this year's crop. An overloaded tree puts everything into seeds and forms no buds, so it crops heavily one year and blanks the next. Thinning early, before the seeds develop, is what breaks that cycle.

Storing the crop

Early apples do not store. They are ready when they are ready, they go mealy within a fortnight, and the only sensible plan is to eat, give away, juice or cook them straight off the tree. Late apples are the opposite and will hold for months in the right conditions.

The conditions are cold, humid and dark: just above freezing, around 32 to 40F (0-4C), with high humidity so the fruit does not shrivel, and good air movement. A cool shed, an unheated garage or a cellar all work; a heated house does not. Keep apples away from potatoes and onions, whose smells they absorb, and away from anything you do not want ripened, because apples give off ethylene.

Store only perfect fruit. Anything bruised, punctured, scabbed or without its stalk goes on the eating pile. Lay the keepers in a single layer, not touching, in slatted trays, or wrap each one in paper so that a rot cannot spread by contact. Check the trays every couple of weeks and remove anything soft.

Apple typeStorage lifeConditionsBest use
Early1-2 weeksCool larder, single layerEat fresh, juice, cook at once
Mid-season4-8 weeks35-40F (2-4C), humid, darkEating through autumn
Late keeper3-6 months32-38F (0-3C), humid, dark, airyWinter eating and cooking
Bruised or stalklessDaysAnywhere coolUse immediately or freeze cooked

Do not wash apples before storing. The natural bloom on the skin slows moisture loss, and any water left in the stalk cavity is where rot starts.

What to record at harvest

Write down the date you took the first sound apple off each tree and the date you finished, and pair it with the full-bloom date you recorded in spring. The gap between them is your days-from-bloom figure, and after two seasons it is the most accurate ripeness predictor you will ever have for that particular tree.

Also record the rough weight or count, whether you thinned and how hard, and how the stored fruit behaved: which trays went soft first and how far into winter the last apples lasted. A tree that cropped heavily and was not thinned tells you, in next year's blank, exactly why thinning was worth the afternoon.

Read next

Keep a growing history for Apple

Type the plant name, add the planting date, and take photos as it grows. Next season you will have your own dates for sowing, flowering, and harvest instead of a generic calendar.

Free on iPhone. Android coming later.

Gadenin free garden journalGet the app