Gadenin日本語Get the app

Job's Tears Problems: Smut, Stem Borers, Birds, Lodging and Beads That Never Harden

Job's Tears is tough, but a long wet season brings smut and borers, and the commonest disappointment of all is simply a crop that runs out of warm weather before the beads harden.

Beads that stay green and never harden

This is the failure that catches most people, and it is not a disease. Job's Tears needs 120 to 150 days of genuine warmth to bring beads to full hardness, and it sets new beads continuously up the stem right until it is stopped. If the season is short, or the sowing went in too early into cold soil and sat, or the plant was pushed with nitrogen into making leaf instead of flowering, you reach frost with a plant full of soft green beads and nothing to show.

The fix is entirely at the front of the season: sow into soil that has genuinely reached 65F (18C), or start indoors four weeks ahead and transplant. Do not add nitrogen after the knee-high stage. If your site is marginal, accept that only the lowest third of each stem will ripen and plan the harvest around that, picking the lower axils diligently rather than waiting for the whole plant.

ProblemWhat you seeCauseWhat to do
Soft green beads at frostWhole plant loaded, none hardSeason too short or sown coldSow later into warm soil, or start indoors
SmutBeads swollen, split, full of black powderWet season, seedborne and soil-borneRemove and bin infected stems, rotate off the ground
Stem borerStem snaps, dead central shootLarvae tunneling inside the stemCut out and destroy affected stems, clear stubble
BirdsBeads stripped from upper axilsRipening beads at eye level for birdsNet, or pick over more often
Leaf blightLong brown lesions on lower leavesCrowding and still, humid airThin weak tillers, widen spacing next year
Flattened clumpsStems down after a stormTop-heavy growth on soft stemsEarth up and corral early with twine

Smut in the beads

Smut is the disease worth knowing by sight. Affected beads swell to an odd, lumpy shape, fail to develop a proper glossy shell and eventually split to release a mass of dry black powder. It spreads in wet, warm weather, which is exactly the weather this crop wants, so a good growing year is also a good smut year.

There is no spray worth using in a garden. Manage it by removal and by hygiene. Cut out and bin affected stems as soon as you spot the swelling, before the beads split and shed spores over the whole planting. Do not compost them. At the end of the season pull and remove all stubble rather than digging it in, and do not grow Job's Tears on the same ground two years running. Save seed only from clean clumps, and never from a plant that carried any smutted beads, because the spores travel on the seed surface.

Borers, birds and the things that eat the crop

Stem borers are the main insect problem in warm regions. The first sign is a single stem in a clump whose central leaves have gone dead and straw-colored while the rest of the plant is fine, or a stem that snaps cleanly in wind at a point where you can see a small entry hole and frass. Cut the affected stem out at the base and destroy it; the larva is inside and leaving it there simply seeds next year's population. Clearing all stubble in autumn matters more than anything you can do in season, because that is where the larvae overwinter.

Birds work the ripening beads on the grain form and largely ignore the hard bead form, which they cannot break. Because the beads ripen individually rather than in a head, bird damage is slower and less catastrophic than in a headed grain, but over six weeks it adds up. Netting a small planting is straightforward; on a larger one, shortening the interval between pick-overs to four days is usually the more practical answer.

Slugs and rodents matter mainly on the ground. Beads that drop and lie in damp mulch are taken quickly, which is another reason to lay a sheet under the clumps and to pick over often rather than letting the drop accumulate.

  1. Walk the planting weekly from flowering Look for a single dead shoot in an otherwise healthy clump, for any swollen misshapen bead, and for beads stripped from the upper axils. All three are far cheaper to catch early.
  2. Cut and destroy rather than treat Smutted stems and bored stems both go out with the rubbish, not on the compost pile. Neither problem has a home treatment that beats removal.
  3. Clear the stubble in autumn Pull the whole clump, roots and all, once the last pick-over is done. Do not leave standing stems over winter; they house borer larvae and carry smut spores through to spring.
  4. Rotate the ground Leave at least two years before Job's Tears goes back on the same bed, and keep it away from ground that carried other grasses last year.

It escapes, and in warm regions it becomes a weed

This is the hazard that outlives the season. Job's Tears self-seeds enthusiastically. Beads drop, lie in the soil over winter and come up thickly the following spring, and in warm, wet regions it has naturalised along ditches and waterways and is treated as an invasive weed. Before you plant, check whether it is regulated or discouraged where you live, because in some warm areas it is.

Even where it is not a legal problem, contain it. Do not plant it next to a stream, a ditch, an irrigation channel or a damp field margin, because water moves the beads a long way. Pick up the drop rather than leaving it; a sheet under the clumps serves this purpose as much as it serves the harvest. Pull volunteer seedlings in spring while they are small, which is easy, rather than in midsummer when the roots are well established and a clump takes real effort to lift.

Note in your records any spot where volunteers came up and how many. Two seasons of that record tells you whether your containment is working or whether the planting is slowly walking across the garden.

If you decide to stop growing it, keep pulling volunteers for at least three springs. Beads left in the soil stay viable for more than one winter, and a bed that looked clean the first spring after can produce a fresh flush the second.

Read next

Keep a growing history for Job's Tears

Type the plant name, add the planting date, and take photos as it grows. Next season you will have your own dates for sowing, flowering, and harvest instead of a generic calendar.

Free on iPhone. Android coming later.

Gadenin free garden journalGet the app