Gadenin日本語Get the app

Pickling Shallot Growing Calendar: Autumn Planting to Early Summer Lifting

Planted in autumn, growing through the cool months, lifted in early summer when the tops die back. Here is the whole cycle, plus the choice between lifting after one year or two.

A reversed year

The calendar for this crop runs opposite to most vegetables. The bulbs go in during autumn, the plant does its growing through the cool months when the beds are otherwise quiet, and it shuts down for summer rather than through winter. That makes it an unusually easy crop to fit into a plot, because it occupies ground precisely when other things do not and asks for almost nothing during the busiest weeks of the year.

Two decisions shape the whole cycle. The first is when to plant, which is governed by soil temperature falling rather than by any date on a calendar. The second is when to lift, which is governed entirely by the tops dying back. Everything else, including hilling and the very small amount of feeding and watering involved, hangs off those two points.

The year in phases

Read the table below as the shape of the year rather than a fixed timetable, and adjust it by watching soil temperature and the state of the tops. The same sequence works in either hemisphere.

PhaseWhat the plant is doingWhat you doDecision point
Autumn plantingRooting from the dormant bulbPlant six inches (15 cm) apart, tip at the surfaceSoil at planting depth below 68F (20C) and falling
Late autumnFirst tops up, division beginning undergroundWeed by hand; water only if the ground is dustyGreen tips showing within two to four weeks
Early winterSteady leaf growth in mild climatesFirst hilling once tops are six to eight inches (15 to 20 cm)Clump visibly widening at the base
Deep winterSlow or stalled; tops may die back in cold areasMulch loosely in hard-winter areas; otherwise leave aloneFrost heave lifting clumps means firm them back in
Early springStrong regrowth, clump dividing fastWeed thoroughly; one light low-nitrogen dressing on poor sand onlyTops lengthening again after winter
Mid springBulbs forming and swellingSecond hilling; stop all feedingClump full width, tops still fully green
Late springBulbs sizing up, reserves moving downStop watering entirely; keep the row weededFirst yellow leaf tips appear
Early summerTops yellow, flop and dry to strawLift on a dry day, split, sort, pickle or cook within daysTops fully down and soil dry
Midsummer to late summerReplanting bulbs dormant in storeDry replant stock two to three weeks in shade, then store cool and airyWait for soil to cool before planting again

One year or two: a real choice

The standard cycle lifts the crop after a single winter, in the first early summer. Each planted bulb gives roughly ten to fifteen bulbs of a good, even size, plump enough to trim and clean without frustration. That is the right choice if you want bulbs for pickling whole and you value ease of preparation.

Leaving the clumps in the ground for a second year is not neglect and not a mistake. The clump goes dormant through the first summer, wakes with the cooling weather, and divides again through the second cool season. When you lift the following early summer you get thirty or more bulbs from the original one, each noticeably smaller, denser and firmer. Some growers prefer exactly that: small bulbs pickle firmer, keep their crunch longer and are quicker to fill a jar with, at the cost of far more trimming per pound.

If you go for two years, plant more widely at the start, eight to ten inches (20 to 25 cm) apart, and expect to weed the wider bed carefully through the first season. Give the bed nothing over the first summer dormancy: no water, no feed, no cultivation near the clumps. Simply mark the row clearly and leave it alone until the tops reappear in autumn.

ApproachBulbs per original plantingBulb sizeBest suited to
Lift after one winterTen to fifteenLarger, even, easy to trimPickling whole with minimum preparation
Leave two yearsThirty or moreSmall, dense, very firmGrowers who want the crispest small bulbs
Mixed row, half and halfBothBoth grades in one bedDeciding which you prefer in your own kitchen

A mixed row is the sensible first-year experiment. Lift half the bed at the first early summer, leave the other half marked and untouched, and compare the two harvests directly a year apart before committing the whole bed either way.

The records that turn this into your own calendar

Published calendars are approximations; yours is not. Write down the planting date and the soil temperature you planted at, the date green tips broke the surface, the dates of both hillings, the date the first tops yellowed, and the date you lifted. After a single season those points give you a calendar tuned to your own garden and remove nearly all the guesswork from the second year.

Add the numbers next to the dates: bulbs planted, bulbs lifted, bulbs kept back, bulbs lost to rot or sprouting before you could use them. The number lost to sprouting is the one most gardeners underestimate, and it tells you honestly how many clumps you can afford to lift in a single day next time.

Finally, note the bed. Allium rotation depends on knowing where the alliums were three and four years ago, and a small plot changes shape faster than memory keeps up with. A sketch of the plot each autumn, with the row marked on it, is worth more here than any other note you make.

Read next

Keep a growing history for Rakkyo

Type the plant name, add the planting date, and take photos as it grows. Next season you will have your own dates for sowing, flowering, and harvest instead of a generic calendar.

Free on iPhone. Android coming later.

Gadenin free garden journalGet the app