Gadenin日本語Get the app

Harvesting Bunching Shallot: Cutting Greens for Repeated Regrowth

Cut the tops an inch above the soil and the clump regrows in two to three weeks, over and over. Cut too low or too often and you exhaust the bulbs, so learn where the line is.

Cut, do not pull

The whole value of this crop is that it regrows. Pulling a plant out gives you one bunch and ends it; cutting the tops gives you a bunch now and another in two or three weeks from the same clump, repeatedly through autumn, winter and spring. Treat every clump as a permanent fixture and take only leaves from it.

Cut with scissors or a sharp knife, one inch (2.5 cm) above the soil. That leaves the growing point and a short collar of leaf base intact, and new leaf pushes from it almost immediately. Cutting flush with the soil takes the growing point with it and that shoot never comes back, though its neighbors in the clump will.

Cutting heightResultTime to next cut
One inch (2.5 cm) above soilClean regrowth from every shootTwo to three weeks in mild weather
Flush with the soilCut shoots do not return; clump thinsFour weeks or more, from surviving shoots only
Halfway up the leafRagged brown tips on every stubFast but the harvest looks poor
Whole clump liftedOne harvest, plant finishedNot applicable

Know when the tops are worth cutting

The tops are ready when they stand eight to ten inches (20 to 25 cm) tall and feel firm and hollow rather than soft. Below about six inches (15 cm) there is barely anything worth taking, and cutting that early costs the plant more than it gives you. Above about fourteen inches (35 cm) the older outer leaves start to flop and yellow at the tip, so aim to cut before that.

In cool, bright conditions a clump goes from cut to cuttable in two to three weeks. As temperatures rise towards summer the interval shortens at first and then the quality drops away as the plant prepares for dormancy. Late-spring growth is often the thickest and best of the whole year, so make the most of it.

  1. Take a third of the clump at a time Rather than shearing the whole clump, cut a third of the shoots and leave the rest standing. The remaining leaves keep feeding the bulbs, so regrowth on the cut portion is faster and the clump never runs down.
  2. Rotate around the bed Work through the row clump by clump so each one gets three or four weeks between cuts. With six clumps in rotation you can cut something every week without pushing any single plant.
  3. Cut in the morning Tops cut in the cool of the morning are turgid and keep far better than the same leaves cut in afternoon heat, which go limp within an hour.
  4. Use a clean blade Wipe the scissors between clumps if any plant shows disease. Cut surfaces on alliums are an easy entry point, and moving spores clump to clump on a blade is a real risk with rust and downy mildew.

Green tops do not store well. They keep three or four days upright in a jar of water in a cool place, or about a week wrapped loosely in the refrigerator. Cut what you need rather than harvesting ahead.

Stop cutting when the plant tells you to

Two signals mean stop. The first is late spring approaching summer, when the tops begin to yellow from the tip and the regrowth after a cut comes back thin and pale. That is dormancy starting, and the plant is moving reserves down into the bulbs. Cutting through that period strips the reserves it needs to survive the dry months, and you will lift undersized, soft bulbs that store badly.

The second is a clump that has simply been overworked. If regrowth after a cut is noticeably thinner than the cut before, and the shoots come up narrow and light green, give that clump six weeks completely untouched and a feed. It recovers, but only if you leave it alone.

The bulbs are a harvest too

When you lift and split clumps in summer, you get far more bulbs than you need to replant. A clump of eight shoots yields eight bulbs and you may only want three of them back in the ground. The surplus is food, with a flavor between a shallot and a spring onion, and it can be used fresh or dried down and kept.

Sort as you lift. Keep the largest, firmest, best-shaped bulbs for replanting, because bulb size at planting drives how many offsets you get next season. Eat the small ones, the misshapen ones and anything with a soft spot, and eat them promptly rather than trying to store them.

Record the date of each cut and roughly how much you took per clump. Within one season those notes give you your own true regrowth interval and show exactly which clumps are carrying the row and which are running down.

Read next

Keep a growing history for Wakegi Onion

Type the plant name, add the planting date, and take photos as it grows. Next season you will have your own dates for sowing, flowering, and harvest instead of a generic calendar.

Free on iPhone. Android coming later.

Gadenin free garden journalGet the app